I know you all want to hear what happened yesterday at Irvine’s 2020 Main Street, Ground Zero for Proposition 8, the Anti-Marriage Initiative. At 5:30 sharp the entire north side of the building was locked down, as well as every door but one on the south side, for the grand opening of the new offices of Schubert Flint, the Red-OC-connected consultants for the initiative. Folks who worked on the other ten floors of the building were dismayed and angered at having to get past so much security – six extra rent-a-cops – just to return to their jobs from a cigarette break, and wondered what kind of dangerous, top-secret work their new eleventh-floor neighbor was up to.
Like K. in Kafka’s The Castle, all I wanted to do was to get up to the open house itself, just to quietly observe, see what sorts of men and women these might be who would devote so much effort into fighting marriage equality, see how they thought and if any of them would admit they think Prop 8 is mainly a good way to get Christian conservatives to the polls to vote Republican, catch some of their talking points and maybe some of their strategy, and if I heard or saw anything especially absurd or offensive, maybe work it into a snarky post here.
But lo, my name was not on the guest list! So I told the receptionists that I was Vern Nelson, a guest of Matt “Jubal” Cunningham, as I knew he was expecting me. Their eyes lit up “We know Matt” and they speed-dialed him to make sure I was OK, but as they listened to his voice they turned downcast: “I’m sorry, sir, this is a private event.” (Matt later wrote “Vern Nelson tried to lie his way into the event.” No. For one thing, he had very plainly written on his blog “Come To Schubert Flint Public Affairs’ Open House,” and how was I to know that invitation was not directed at me? Plus, if I wanted to lie I would have RSVP’d under a fake name, or claimed to be one of the people whose name tags were sitting out all over the table – they weren’t checking IDs. I just thought Matt MIGHT be a good sport and let a fellow blogger come in. Silly huh.)
The reason for all the security precautions, locked doors and rent-a-cops, was simply some blustery posts from a day earlier promising big protests – originally written by the brilliant Chino Blanco on the various leftwing sites and then picked up by Andrew at the Liberal OC – posts that threw the high-strung Jubal into a panic. As it turned out, a half-dozen humanists showed up to hand out the following masterful Chino Blanco flyer to passersby. These flyers were greatly appreciated by the other occupants of 2020 Main, as it explained why they were being so inconvenienced; It may be a good idea for some of us to go back soon and deliver a dozen more of these to each business there. (link to PDF file here if you want to print some up yourself: http://www.echols.info/SF-Irvine-Aug-14-Flyer.pdf )
(I like that: “When do we get to vote on your marriages?”)
The most entertaining part of this very entertaining thread from Andrew’s story is watching the kaleidoscope of emotions Jubal goes thru when he hears there may be a protest at the carefully-planned open house which he had rashly publicized on his Red-faced County. The first vision he gets is of jackboots; then after a fitful night’s sleep he wakes up seeing left-wing mobs using “street tactics,” and his racing mind begins to reach. At 8:40 AM he demands my (and Andrew’s) home address because protesting there would be just like protesting at a political consultant’s office. At 8:52 the Blogger Who Cannot Tell A Lie tries to make everyone think the event had already happened the day before. Later, with assistance from his sidekick d’Anconia, he introduces the idea that consultants exist on some level above politics and morality and hence we should instead protest at some nonexistent Campaign Headquarters for Proposition 8.
After what seems a lifetime later, the successful open house come and gone unmolested, the dishes washed and folding chairs returned, and all the little Jubalettes tucked soundly in bed, he relaxes at his keyboard and lets loose his elation: our whole effort was “a big flop. Big, Flop.” We were a “puny posse,” a “complete failure,” a “c-o-m-p-l-e-t-e bust.”
Funny, where Jubal saw our failure, I saw our success: With only the minimal number of participants you’d expect at such short notice, we caused the enemies of marriage equality to spend hundreds (if not thousands) of extra homophobe money on security, and irritate the hell out of their new co-tenants.
We demonstrated that plotting against something as harmless and benign as same-sex marriage, which has been gaining acceptance by leaps and bounds, is no longer something that can be done out in the open.
The only failure I regret is not being a fly on the wall upstairs. If I had been, I may have come up with observations and conclusions like Calitics’ D-Day:
This report of a national conference call to fight … marriage equality sounds more like a battle plan than a political strategy session. All the leading figures of the religious right were there, and the language is undeniably militaristic. I believe that the best way to counteract the theocratic right is to display them in all their radicalism, so the whole country understands the goals of their movement. So here ya go:
The primary focus of the call was Proposition 8 in California, described by (Chuck) Colson as “the Armageddon of the culture war.” Many speakers invoked the language of warfare, raising up an army of believers, putting soldiers in the streets, being on the front lines of a battle. Lou Engle actually described a massive rally planned in Qualcomm stadium on November 1 as a “blitzkrieg moment.”
While speaker after speaker spoke of the dire threats same-sex married couples pose to “traditional” marriage, religious freedom, and civilization itself, the overall tone of the call was confidence that victory would be won with God’s help, 40 days of prayer and fasting before the election, teams of intercessors and prayer warriors around the country, and a massive highly organized deployment of volunteers in a systematic voter identification and turnout campaign.This is not exactly the stuff of democracy, nor is it in any way reflective of a country with a separation of church and state. What is at work here is a putsch, a desire to seize the instruments of power and subjugate everyone to one belief system. They mobilize through fear, claiming that the next steps in the fiendish plan are to ban the Bible, legalize polygamy, and “destroy marriage”. They’re also using supposedly apolitical churches as an illegal communications apparatus:
Ron Luce from Teen Mania ministries and other organizers talked about plans to organize 300,000 youth and their families for an October 1 simulcast, and using them to reach 2.4 million. A representative of the Church Communication Network, a satellite network that has downlink equipment in 500 churches in California, 95 in Arizona, and 321 in Florida, said it would simulcast the youth event free of charge, and would make a satellite dish available “at cost” to churches who don’t yet have one. Said one speaker of the youth organizing, “if we don’t use them, Satan will.”
That is manifestly against the spirit of tax-exempt laws regarding churches – laws which I imagine you’ll see broken many times between now and November. The free simulcasting and satellite services amount to in-kind donations.People for the American Way is on this and keeping tabs on the theocratic right. As I said, forewarned is forearmed – there’s a growing segment of the state and the country who are repulsed by this fundamentalism, this anti-Democratic dominionism. We have an opportunity this fall to lay bare the innate bigotry of their movement for all to see.
UPDATE: Another aspect to this is the exhuming once again of far-right theocratic icon Alan Keyes, who’s running for President again – but only in California, as part of the American Independent Party (formed in 1968 by segergationist George Wallace, which is somewhat ironic). His running mate is Rev. Wiley Drake, the minister who prayed for the death of members of Americans United for Separation of Church and State last year. The fundies are lining up, packed in two at a time, and all headed to California in lockstep. It’s going to be crazy out here for the next 95 days.
In conclusion, I really think it’s important to reprint a comment from the thread referenced above. For as much fun as we have on both sides hurling banter, taunts and arguments at each other while calculating political damage and gain, this comment from “Richard” reminds us of the real injustice that Jubal, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns and their ilk are fighting to perpetuate, while the rest of us fight to end it:
Just for the record, here in a northern California county, on January 27th, my beloved husband died. We were registered Domestic Partners with the Secretary of State. Had been since 2001. But Domestic Partners really is 2nd class – no it really is no class here.
He died at home so the Deputy Sheriff acted as Coroner. He refused to recognize me as next of kin. He insisted we call a blood relative in New York State to choose a funeral home etc. He wanted to remove all of my beloved’s possesions from our home and ship them back East … including his wedding ring. It was a Sunday night so I could not get the County judge or attorney to set things right (as I did on Monday) I had to lie and weasle to keep our stuff in our home. Because I did not count at all. Our family did not count. We were 2nd class – no class. Because we were not married.
Don’t tell me that Domestic Partnership is just as good as marriage. And don’t tell me that I was not married in my heart AND in my church to my husband. The Court just recognized what is a fact … he and I were married … and it is a civil right.
You have no idea how much it hurt … still hurts … that in 2008, in California, my family was ignored when I needed it to be recognized the most.
It was an open house for Schubert Flint not for Prop 8…so I hate to burst your bubble, but any extra money for security did not come from Prop 8.
Don’t bother Vern with the facts, Flowerszzz. It gets in the way of his yarn-spinning.
Fungibility. All you guys got?
LOL I could care less I just love how the drama spins here.
The prop may or may not win….but history has been it wins….every time it is on the ballot. Bottom line people say they dont care about the marriages, but when they vote they vote against it.
Jeez, zzz, “I could care less…” What public spirit, you must a been raised on the Reg. Well now it’s about people who do care: get outta the way!
Yay VERN!!!!!!
‘Ron Luce from Teen Mania ministries and other organizers talked about plans to organize 300,000 youth and their families for an October 1 simulcast, and using them to reach 2.4 million.‘
Ahh… the big tobacco strategy. Get ’em while they’re young, eh? That’s just sick. Joe Camel made cigarettes ‘cool’ and now Jeff Flint is attempting to do the same for hatred and discrimination.
Children should be brought up to keep their minds open and make their own decisions about these types of things, not be encouraged to hate others’ whose business is none of theirs. ‘Protect marriage… family values,’ indeed.
‘Don’t tell me that Domestic Partnership is just as good as marriage. And don’t tell me that I was not married in my heart AND in my church to my husband. The Court just recognized what is a fact … he and I were married … and it is a civil right.‘
I still think we should strengthen civil unions and give the option to hets as well, but this upset me quite a bit; this gentleman was treated like he wasn’t even human. For REAL equality, vote NO ON 8!
SMS
Vern
a great post—
what we must remember is that Jubal is a dogmatic Catholic in spite of his Servite education. Somebody says jump (most likely Urell) and these idiots say how high.
When I attended Servite (and yes Jubal, despite what you think and say, I am a graduate and I do get the ALUMNI directory-BTW you havent answered the question I posed to you-Again-what is alcarbon? besides an email address name?), the education was centered on the intellectual development of the individual so that he could in fact think for himself and make a positive contribution to his community and to society as a whole. What the Servite system did was to create a thoughtful individual (and yes there is a Servite High School in Detroit-not only in Anaheim) dedicated to making a contribution to this country.
The Servite system has produced its share of Jubals. Not everyone can adapt to the idea of thinking on their own and making decisions for themselves. Jubal is a prime example of the dogmatic Catholics that exist. Remember that many Catholics (not all Servite grads) are thinking Catholics and it drives the conservative element of the Church hierarchy nuts.
Jubal has to provide for his family and for that he is to be commended for exercising some degree of responsibility. But you have to keep in mind that people like Schubert/ Flint/ Cunningham are dealing with a shrinking base of support. Centrist Republicans (we are thinking Republicans) realize that these clowns are putting the party in a position where it will be a non player.
To get a better sense of what drives people like Flint and Cunningham, just watch the Bill Moyers Jounal piece entitled Capital Crimes. It highlights Abramhoff, Ralph Reed, and Grover the Raging Bull Norquist. I believe it was broadcast on August 1.
It clearly illustrates the depths that these types will go. The only difference between them and Flint/Cunningham is the stage-the philosophical mindset is the same.
I am sure that Jubal will do some work for Flint. You could protest outside his office in Orange. Just check his business website-Pacific-Strategies.com.
Dont give up the effort on defeating Prop 8. These characters have their heads in the sand and are in it for the money (watch the Moyers piece on Capital Crimes). Dont let up.
If Prop 8 is defeated in November, it will be a HUGE victory for civil rights and a crushing defeat for the radical religious right. The more I hear how much the far right wants it to pass, the more convinced I am that the defeat of Prop 8 will be like sticking a knife in the religious right’s political movement and twisting the hell out of it! Add an Obama Presidential victory and Democratic Congressional victories, and November could be the beginning of the end of the politics of hate.
Robin Tyler and her wife (the first same-sex couple married in California after Prop 22 was struck down) were the guests at the Americans United meeting earlier today, and I liked her idea for an anti-8 slogan: “Stop the Hate. No On 8!”
Carl
you are right on point. I would suggest reading the PPIC and Field Polls done over the last two months on Prop 8. Its proponents sued and lost last week on the ballot title (they sued Jerry Brown) in our local Sac court and then went right across to Federal Court to appeal the local decision. They were told to pound sand on that appeal.
Their public pronouncements were to the effect that the voters of California would come out in astronomical numbers (they drew the parallel to prop 22 when it passed) to support Prop 8.
When you look at the proponents, most of them are out of state individuals associated with Liberty University (Jerry Falwell) and Pat Robertson as well as James Dobson (Focus on the Family).
Locally here, the Capital Resource Institute, led by Karen England, is a key player in the support effort of Prop 8. Schubert/Flint are involved in the campaign. When you strip away the verbage and play connect the dots, these individuals are what I would describe as the religious taliban of California.
People like Jeff Flint, Matt Cunningham, Craig Deluz (a capital staffer here who sits on a local school board and lost his race for central committee in June), Karen England, Meredith Turney, Jon Fleischman—If you look at the people who write (not anonymously) on RedCounty and the Flash Report, and dig into their backgrounds, it is not hard to discern their religious leanings and how they incorporate those sentiments into “Republican Values”.
This is the premise which underpins a resurgent effort by centrist and moderate Republicans to take back the California Republican Party from these religious fanatics. If these Talibani Republicans continue in their fanatical efforts, the Republican party will continue its deep slide.
I would refer you to Bill Moyers Report on PBS. He recently did a piece entitled Capital Crimes which profiles Jack Abramhoff, Ralph Reed, and Grover Norquist and the religious right at the Federal level. You can see it in their archives section on line. It is a brilliant piece of investigative journalism.
The Flints, Englands, Cunninghams, Deluzs, Turneys, and Fleischmanns of California are the religious talibani of California. We must be always vigiliant of these folks and their associates.
Great post – and the comments you get here from so many different points along the political spectrum – makes for a good read.
Chino Blanco – nice flyer!
Vern, thanks for another great post. I especially liked the reprint from Calitics.
Commenters, thanks for a great discussion.
O/T (sorry)
LDS (Mormon) ‘Yes on 8’ Game Plan
I’ve posted a letter sent from Boyd K. Packer on July 28th to the California LDS stake presidents:
http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2008/8/19/224211/910/755/570793
Apparently, there is a plan in place to put up one million ‘Yes on 8’ yard signs at 7:00 am on September 22nd.