Fullerton District 4-Gate: One Fake Candidate, or Two? Let’s see…

You come to the Orange Juice Blog for the Straight Dope right? So here goes.

But before we get rolling with the ’24 Fullerton Council lowdown, let’s dispense with this one DEFINITE fake candidate, this Scott Markowitz. Till recently a Democrat but now registered Republican, Scott was put into this race by Democrat operatives in an obvious effort to bleed away conservative votes from Republican Linda Whitaker, and his candidate statement includes a call to “America First Patriots to step up!” and vote for him. (You can picture a few Democrats sitting around giggling when they came up with that.)

Nobody should be silly enough to vote for Scott, not even whatever Trumpies may live in Fullerton, although some of them are so dumb they probably will (if they bother to read his statement.) Scott has raised less than $1000 for this race and has no website or Facebook, and we’re sure that Scott himself and his family will be voting for establishment Democrat Kitty Jaramillo, whom his candidacy is intended to help.

The SAME Democrat operatives pulled this same trick two years ago to help establishment Democrat Ahmad Zahra, running one Tony Castro to pull Latino votes away from serious candidate Oscar Valadez in that majority-Latino district. And the trick worked. But things are even messier this time around.

Because, who is this Jamie Valencia, Latina Democrat supported by some of the same folks (you’d think would be) backing Whitaker? Is this not one more fake candidate balancing off Markowitz, to take votes from Kitty Jaramillo, for net-zero fake candidacies and max confusion? That was MY first impression, but we will have to look at this closer. Somebody told the Liberal OC’s Dan Chmielewksi a little bit about this, and Dan produced an illiterate miasma of words and documents that’ll leave any unfortunate reader more confused than before.

[Update: Ah, I shouldn’t “bury my lede” at the bottom of this story: Jamie is a legit, serious candidate and a good Democrat.]


But before proceeding, we need to lay some groundwork:

Fullerton’s Two Camps (these days)

Every city in the OC has its own breakdown during these interesting times, during these long death throes of the OC GOP. Things don’t usually break down simply between D vs. R, as they do in Huntington Beach. In Santa Ana the long-dominant Dems split into two fiercely opposed camps of progressives and corporatists. In Irvine sundry Democrats who loathe each other make confusing, awkward alliances with sundry Republicans. In Anaheim it doesn’t matter what Party you’re in, Disney tells you what to do. And this is how the two “camps” in Fullerton appear to me, excuse me if I simplify:

  • BIPARTISAN PRAGMATISTS who are now a 3-member majority of Democrat Fred Jung and Republicans Bruce Whitaker and Nick Dunlap, funded by (but not always co-operative with) the Bushala family; and supported by the scabrous (and sometimes unfair) Friends For Fullerton’s Future (FFFF.)
  • ESTABLISHMENT DEMOCRATS so called because they’re currently backed by the DPOC, led by controversial councilman Ahmad Zahra, and generally supported by the Kennedy family’s generally liberal (and arguably “yellowing”) Fullerton Observer. (I should mention I learn a lot from both these outlets.)

This season ALL THREE OF THE BIPARTISAN PRAGMATISTS ARE UP – Jung and Dunlap for re-election, and Whitaker termed out. So the Establishment Democrats are trying to knock off one-to-three of them, but they really only seem to be trying hard in Whitaker’s District 4.

But now, if you have a brain, you ask “What do these two camps STAND for? What do they want to change in Fullerton, what do they want to keep the same? Or are they just two implacable, power-hungry cliques that hate each other?” Good questions which we shall endeavor to answer below:

District 1: Fred Jung v. Matt Truxaw


The critics of Fred Jung are all establishment Democrats who think the world of Ahmad Zahra, and if you ask them, they’ll tell you Fred is a “shitty Democrat.” Except, their only example of Fred’s Democrat-shittiness is that he refuses to ever let Zahra be Mayor or Mayor Pro-Tem (ceremonial titles by the way; and Fred’s reason is his first-hand experience of Ahmad’s disqualifying behavior. But seriously read this 2020 classic from Dan. Comments section especially!)

“That is so stupid,” says Fred. “Actually, apart from the fact that I’ll never support him for a leadership position, Ahmad and I vote the same about 90% of the time.

“Why ARE you a Democrat anyway?”

“Good question. You may not know it but I’m an Evangelical Christian…” (and as an aside he says the Democratic Party should not write off Evangelicals and assume they’re all gonna be right-wingers.) “I’ve been a Democrat since the Obama years. My Christianity leads me to believe in equality, in caring for the less fortunate, in supporting women’s right to choose, in people having the right to love who they choose, in we humans being stewards of the Earth.”

“Stewards of the Earth – is that why you are so passionate about the OCPA?” (OC Power Authority)

“Yes! And I’m really proud of how we’ve turned that around in less than a year – we can offer consumers energy for 3% less than SCE charges, and it’s 100% clean! We’ll be having more cities signing on in the coming year…”

“Is Fullerton’s membership in OCPA in jeopardy, if Ahmad wins the majority this year?” I asked, knowing that Ahmad was always railing against the agency in its first couple (incompetent, corrupt) years, and hanging it around Fred’s neck.

“No,” Fred laughed, “nobody is going to want to leave now.”

Fred’s biggest concern is Fullerton’s crumbling infrastructure, and HOW TO GET SOME REVENUE to fix that – and he and the Council have started an “ad-hoc committee” to look at various options including a sales tax, which many other OC cities are looking at. Hard to be enthusiastic about a sales tax in these trying times. I tell him, “FFFF seems to think the solution is in taxing the downtown bars more, as they’re so profitable and create such nuisance.” “Well, we’ll be looking at that along with everything else. But Downtown Fullerton is not what it used to be before COVID, not as profitable AND less of a nuisance.” Fred named, as his representative on this revenue committee, Tony Bushala, “because I trust his judgment.”

But Fred and his majority don’t always do what the Bushalas want, as in their unanimous vote for the Union Pacific Trail, which Bushala and FFFF regularly trashed as a pointless “Trail to Nowhere.” “That was a no-brainer, and it is NOT a ‘trail to nowhere,'” retorts Fred. “It was state-funded, and South Fullerton needs it and deserves it. That part of the town has always been neglected, and they should have a way to hike & bike to other parts of Fullerton.” So much for Ahmad’s myth that the majority voted “NO” on it, which Dan is still repeating – Fred just wanted to look at other options before committing.

Another long-time Democrat is the guy who filed to run against Fred this year, one Matt Truxaw… except he re-registered as a Republican, presumably to be a more credible opponent to Fred. According to SoCal Daily Pulse, none other than Ahmad Zahra has been trying to pull strings to get some institutional Republican support for Matt, but somehow Ahmad doesn’t have much cachet with that crowd – go figure!

Matt told me on Facebook “I really don’t want to get into tearing down my opponent. I want to focus on a positive message for what I can do for the City and the people of Fullerton.” But apparently he’s had second thoughts (as an opponent SHOULD) and has been “tearing down” Fred as best he can on his Facebook page, mostly criticizing him for how much of his funding comes from outside Fullerton.

Yeah, THAT. “Geez, Fred, $248K, what do you need that for? You could run in ANAHEIM with that amount.” It DWARFS all the other candidates – 4X more than Nick Dunlap, and over 10X more than any of the others. “Yeah, well, I started fundraising early, as soon as I got elected. And I’m glad I did, regular campaigning is hard for me right now.” (I haven’t mentioned, but Fred has been going through chemo and radiation for a cancerous tumor.)

“And,” I observe, “it’s almost all from Korean-Americans, from all over the southland. A full page in the Observer of Korean-American donors.” “Yeah, well, we Korean-Americans support each other.” Meanwhile Truxaw has yet to raise $1000, and has no endorsements listed on his website. I don’t think the Zahra camp is taking this race too seriously.

This one either:

District 2: Nick Dunlap vs. Jan Flory


I don’t know much about Nick. He’s a Republican so we probably disagree on some things; still, on Fullerton issues he mostly votes with Fred so how bad could he be? Nick has raised $63,403, and the lady Dems have put up against him has (like Truxaw and Markowitz) yet to raise $1000. That’s Jan Flory, an octogenarian who’s been in Fullerton politics longer than anyone remembers. She hasn’t bothered to get the DPOC endorsement. If you try to Google her it goes to a Facebook page for her 2012 Council race, and her ancient “FloryForFullerton.com” domain has been squatted on by “The Need To Get A Conveyancing Lawyer When Selling A Property In Brisbane, Queensland.” Seems Jan is coasting on name recognition.

(The re-emergence of Jan Flory, for the benefit of Zahra, reminds us of more hypocrisy from Zahra and his supporters – the unforgiveable sin of Jung passing Zahra over for Mayor in 2020 is exactly what Zahra did two years earlier to Bruce Whitaker for the benefit of … Jan Flory! She owes him.)

It seems the Zahra Democrats aren’t taking district 1 OR 2 too seriously. It seems they’re putting all their eggs into District 4, where if Kitty Jaramillo wins, they’ll have a majority. SO, without further ado…

DISTRICT 4

1. The Whitakers

Dumb Dan identifies Bruce Whitaker as “a termed-out District 4 council member.” Bruce Whitaker is a legend of OC politics. Back during the ’90’s bankruptcy he was part of a bipartisan group of troublemakers (along with my friends Steve White & Sandy Genis) to stop the move to TAX Orange County residents out of the bankruptcy, a move spearheaded by Sheriff Brad Gates. After one particularly successful debate against the Sheriff, the young Bruce was approached by Gates who embraced him and whispered, “Careful driving home tonight.” And sure enough Bruce crashed into some bushes – his brake lines had been cleanly cut. True story!

His many terms on Fullerton Council have been characterized by standing up to powerful special interests including the police union – he and Sharon Quirk-Silva were the only Councilmembers to demand the truth about the killing of Kelly Thomas in 2011, and during his times on the OC Water District he was a steadfast opponent of the Poseidon boondoggle (unlike most Republicans, and unlike Ahmad Zahra when he got his turn.)

On the other hand, sometimes he’s been TOO conservative – for example when he’s rejected state funds for Fullerton just because he doesn’t think the state should be spending that money. That’s called “Cutting off your conservative nose to spite your town’s face.”

But long story short Bruce is termed out this year, and his wife Linda is running to take his place. They are both really nice people, and my friends, and nearly as old as Biden or Jan Flory. This blog (as well as the FFFF) has a long tradition of ridiculing politicians who try running to take their termed-out spouse’s place, especially the Ackermans but there are many other examples (I’ve recently learned handing off a termed-out seat to a family member is practically the rule in Laguna Niguel.) Let’s see, what did I write in 2014’s “The Troubling Case of the Ackerwoman?”

“Another thing we see is… when a politician is so self-enamored that, not only do they project their deep self-love onto the voting public, but they tell themselves, ‘My voters love them some Ackerman (Harman/Galloway/Lopez-Maddox) SO much that, deprived of me as they are by the cruelty of term limits, they’ll JUMP at the chance to get the next best thing in office – my SPOUSE!’

This doesn’t REALLY apply to Bruce and Linda, if you know them – she is just as smart as him, and has always been his top advisor. Still, though, she told a friend of mine (will update this story when I can get a hold of Linda) that she only jumped into the race to stop Kitty Jaramillo from getting on Council. Wow – what is so bad about Kitty Jaramillo?

I call Kitty Jaramillo.

Vivian “Kitty” Jaramillo came to my Democrats Club’s fundraiser for Derek Tran and Frances Marquez (who I think are the two most important candidates in the OC this year) and I appreciate that she came. Shana Charles, the Councilmember not mentioned yet who is generally considered an ally of Zahra, also came to that fundraiser (and later to some of our Club meetings.) Fred says that Shana is very “earnest” and “serious” and “always tries to do what’s best for Fullerton,” even if she does have a soft spot for his nemesis.

So I called Kitty. Her political opponents warned me that she’s “abrasive” and “overly partisan,” but she’s fun to talk to. She’s totally driven by the ghetto conditions of the Southwest Fullerton district she lives in, which looks like it hasn’t been improved since the 1950’s. There are no supermarkets in the whole district – the 99-Cent Store on Orangethorpe closed down recently, and now the Stater Brothers on Euclid & Chapman is closing too. “And none of these knuckleheads in the Council majority care about South Fullerton.”

“We were so excited when a Democrat, Fred Jung, got elected, we thought we FINALLY had a Democrat majority, but that knucklehead votes right down the line with the Republicans.” “I know you guys are mad that they won’t let Ahmad be Mayor or Pro Tem, but what other votes of Fred make you mad?” “That UP Trail, for example, they voted NO on it for TWO YEARS, until the state funding was about to disappear, THEN they finally gave in. And all because Bushala has some commercial property adjoining that trail, and he wanted to make an alley there instead. Well, if I get elected, Ahmad will finally have a majority and we can get to work improving South Fullerton.” Yes, she likes Ahmad – she can only think of one thing she disagrees with him on, and that is, as a renter, she and Shana want overnight parking allowed and Ahmad doesn’t.

“Bruce lives down here, but he acts like he lives up north. When he was opposing the trail, he said, ‘Why can’t south Fullertonians just go up north and enjoy the trails there?’ I told him, ‘I don’t know if you’re ignorant, or racist!'” (I guess that’s why FFFF says that she “allegedly accused him of racism.”) “I ran once in 2012 and promised my husband I’d never run again, but when I heard Linda was running to take his place, I knew I had to run to stop her!” Hmmm, what did come first here?

Here’s something I didn’t know: Fullerton has district elections because Kitty and a young Korean guy called Jonathan Paik sued for it. It probably would’ve eventually happened anyway, but still – Kitty’s the Jose Moreno of Fullerton! FFFF likes to ridicule her once having been a “metermaid,” but most of her professional life was in Code Enforcement in Santa Ana. Kitty is especially emphatic about the need for a full-time city employee specializing in Economic Development.

“If you had a majority would you push for Santa Ana-style rent control, and an inclusionary housing ordinance for affordable housing – like, 15% or at least 10% of any new development?” (Those are things I’m pushing for in Anaheim – hey, I’m progressive!) Kitty says those are great ideas, although Fred says nobody’s brought up either of them since he’s been on Council. (Jesus once mentioned an inclusionary ordinance in passing.)

When I mentioned Jamie Valencia, Kitty did NOT call her a “fake candidate” or a “fake Democrat,” although she did say she never heard of her before she started running. Well, here’s what you’ve all been waiting for:

I Call Jamie Valencia.

You know PROJECTION, that thing Trump does all the time, when you claim your enemy is doing the same thing you’ve been doing, because, you probably figure, why wouldn’t they? That’s how it must be for Establishment Dems after running Castro, Markowitz & Truxal. Heh, I don’t think they’ve even seen this, the final paragraph of the April FFFF piece announcing Linda’s candidacy:

“I wouldn’t be the least bit surprised if the OC Democrats try the same ploy they rolled out in District 5 in 2022; namely, creating a fake candidate to draw votes away from Mrs. Whitaker. On the other hand, this is a heavily Latino district and a Latino candidate or two would certainly have the same effect on Jaramillo.”

Pero no, Jamie is for real. A registered nurse for 18 years, who works at UCLA and at schools in Orange (specializing in “critical care”) she was put onto the Infrastructure and Natural Resources Board by Fred Jung a couple years ago. She’s also on the OCTA citizens advisory board, and some water bill dispute board. And she decided to run for Council a year ago, and started putting things in motion, before she even knew Linda or Kitty were running.

And just like Kitty she complains about the neglect of her area and how there are no supermarkets. But once Kitty jumped in Jamie started getting calls from the DPOC asking her to drop out because they’d already endorsed a candidate. (Shades of Kim Nguyen and Derek Tran, shades of Sukhee Kang and Josh Newman.) Folks and businesses that have endorsed her started getting yelled at and harassed. She is getting really turned off by the Democratic Party.

“It’s just the County Party, don’t give up on the Democrats! The Party needs independent people like you and me and Fred! How long have you been a Democrat?” Jamie has been a Democrat as long as she’s been voting. “Why are you a Democrat?” “Because I care about the people, I want to help people, that’s why I became a nurse too, and the things Republicans say are just…. off the wall, they don’t make sense to me. Plus I care a lot about the environment. I grew up in the mountains, in Mammoth.”

No, nothing fake about Jamie. I mean, there’s no way she’s there to take votes from Kitty so that Linda can win. She’s just piling up the endorsements – the police union, the Carpenters’ Union, and she expects the Fire Union endorsement this week. A lot of folks you woulda thought were backing Linda are with Jamie. Fred likes that she’s “in the workforce, raising a kid, and much closer to the median age of Fullerton which is 35.”

Like her mentor Fred, she rates improving Fullerton’s infrastructure as her top priority. Her Committee has just put in a motion or recommendation to Council for updating and improving the roads near Harbor & Commonwealth. Her other big priority is helping small businesses, finding out what they need from the city to help them thrive and add to the city’s tax base.

A red flag is the large contributions to both Jamie and Fred from Rancho La Paz slumlord John Saunders. Makes one worry. Is he buying up more property in Fullerton? Does he have a development planned? Is he worried that some of the other candidates could make rent control permanent? Jamie and Fred both tell me they met with him and he was impressed with their “pro-business philosophies.” Hmmm. I should mention that, despite all my problems with Zahra, he’s been the only member to help the poor rent-gouged Seniors of Rancho La Paz.

Well, that’s long enough for now! I made fun of Dan’s story for “leaving readers confused,” mine probably will too. But at least it’s all true! Let’s close with a Fullerton song:

About Vern Nelson

Greatest pianist/composer in Orange County, and official political troubadour of Anaheim and most other OC towns. Regularly makes solo performances, sometimes with his savage-jazz band The Vern Nelson Problem. Reach at vernpnelson@gmail.com, or 714-235-VERN.